Mushtaq Bilal, PhD

@MushtaqBilalPhD

personal growth

current affairs

I got rejected during the interview when I applied for a Fulbright scholarship in 2015. Here's why:
First a bit of background A Fulbright application asks for your: • Personal statement • Research statement • 3 letters of recommendation • GRE score • Academic CV Based on these documents, you get shortlisted for an interview.
I submitted my application in May 2015 and got shortlisted for an interview in Sept. I couldn't go past because of the following reasons:
1. Attitude At time I applied I was still working as a naval officer. Militaries all over the world drill a false sense of pride into your head. "An officer can do anything," we were told day in and day out.
Plus I had graduated top of my class in the naval academy, so you can imagine the level of false pride I had at the time. When I got the call for the Fulbright interview, I thought I didn't any preparation. "I was born prepared," I'd say arrogantly whenever my wife asked.
2. Underdressing The haughty attitude I had at the time fed into everything I did. I felt entitled. When the interview date arrived, I didn't even bother dressing up for the occasion. I wore a shirt with khakis and sneakers. No tie, no jacket.
3. Overconfidence The panel started the interview by asking me about myself. I told them a bit my educational background and why I wanted to pursue a PhD in literature. I should've stopped there.
But then I went on to crack a joke — I don't remember it exactly but it was something like I'm good with babies and if you ever need a babysitter, feel free to call me. The joke worked. Everyone on the panel laughed. I felt I had won them over. I should've stopped there.
But a few minutes later, my overconfident ass brought up the whole babysitting joke again. No one laughed this time. An interview is not a place to crack jokes. If you want to, you'd better have a damn good joke.
4. Confrontation Instead of engaging with interviewers' questions respectfully, I confronted them. I started arguing to prove that my point-of-view was correct.
The interview lasted five minutes after which the panel thanked me. They must've breathed a sigh of relief watching me leave the room. "What a colossal prick," I could imagine them saying.
A few weeks later, I received a letter that started with "We regret to inform you..." Had I drafted the letter, I would've written "We don't regret to inform you that your arrogant ass is not entitled to anything."
Anyways, I took the rejection in stride and decided to apply again the next year. Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better. — Samuel Beckett
I revised my personal/research statemens and resubmitted my application in 2016. Again, I got shortlisted for the interview. But this time round I took nothing for granted.
I knew I needed help. So, I started looking up coaches who train people how to interview. It took a bit of work but I found one. I tried booking an appointment for a mock-interview. But the coach said he didn't have any slots open for the next several weeks.
I requested him for a short phone call if getting an appointment was not a possibility. Fortunately, he agreed to a five-minute phone call. That experience combined with the rejection letter really humbled me.
I called the coach and started telling him my sob story: See, I'm so competent, I have such a good CV, and Fulbright people don't recognize my talent, and all that victimhood crap.
30 seconds into it, he told me to shut up in a polite but firm voice. Then he gave me some real tough-love advice. "Just don't behave like an entitled d*ck and you'll be fine," he said before hanging up.
I took his advice seriously. Very seriously. I got a suit dry cleaned and bought a new tie — the same tie that I'm wearing in my profile photo.
I remembered the questions the panel had asked me earlier. I started drafting their answers. Every question had a 3 to 4 lines answer: crisp and to-the-point. I rehearsed the lines multiple times with pauses and breaks, so they'd sound natural and spontaneous.
On 1 Sept. 2017, I received the interview call. On 7 Sept. 2017, I went for the interview. They had called a large group of candidates at 8am. I reached there at 7:30am — all suited up. My turn came at 11:55am.
The panel asked me the same kind of questions. I used some of the lines I had memorized. The rest I improvised. I didn't try to crack any jokes. At the end, I thanked the panel for the opportunity to share my work and thoughts with them.
On 6 Oct. 2017, I received an email that started with the following sentence: "Congratulations! You are among those who have been finally nominated for the Fulbright 2017 cohort." I read the sentence and called my wife.
If you learned something from this thread: 1. Scroll to the top and retweet to share it with your friends so they don't make the same mistakes that I did. 2. Follow me @MushtaqBilalPhD for more threads like this.